The Broder Buck: The World Record Non-Typical Mule Deer

The Largest Mule Deer Ever Killed

The Broder Buck: The World Record Non-Typical Mule Deer

  • The Broder Buck: The World Record Non-Typical Mule Deer
  • Woman Holding the Largest Mule Deer Ever Killed
  • The Broder Buck Score Sheet

Date Killed/Found:

11/25/1926

Estimated Age:

???

Location:

Chip Lake, Alberta,

Terrain:

Pine / Coniferous

Gross Score:

361 6/8 Inches

Net Score:

355 2/8 Inches

Scoreable Points:

43

Spread:

22 1/8 Inches (Inside)

Mass:

5-Inch Base (Right) / 4 4/8-Inch Base (Left)

The Story.

By: Boone & Crockett Club

 

Perhaps one of the most outstanding trophies ever recorded is the world record non-typical mule deer. This deer was taken by Ed Broder in 1926 near Chip Lake, Alberta. Luckily, Broder gave a colorful account of his hunt.

“On November 25, 1926, I and two friends, driving an old 1914 Model T Ford, left Edmonton for Chip Lake, Alberta,” Broder said. “It was a distance of approximately 100 miles. The weather was 20°F with a foot of soft snow. At a sawmill camp, near Chip Lake, we made arrangements to hire a team of horses and a sleigh to haul our gear and equipment. Finding a good cabin near the lake, we used this instead of putting up our tent.

“It was about 1 p.m. when I left camp and set out through some heavy timber,” Broder continued. “Soon, I came across a large deer track. Following the deer tracks for a half mile, I found where [it] had bedded down. Knowing the deer could not be too far away, I tracked [it] off the timber ridge and through a jack pine swamp. There, I found that two moose had crossed the deer’s tracks.”

Then, Broder had to make a life-altering decision. Lucky for him, it was nearing sunset.

“I had to make a decision as to whether to go after the moose or the deer,” Broder said. “Through past experience, I knew moose would travel farther and faster than deer, and with only a short time before dark, I decided to carry on with the deer.

“Following these tracks through the swamp, I came up onto higher land with a clearing not too far off,” Broder continued. “In this clearing I spotted the deer; he was approximately 200 yards away, standing and feeding with [its] back to me. So immediately I had to make a guess as to when and how to shoot. The distance was right, but his position was wrong. I knew I had to select a rear shot. The shot would have to be placed high in the spine, so I pulled up my .32 Winchester Special to a firing position, waited for his head to rise so as to back up a high spine shot. I fired and the animal dropped; I had broken its spine. ‘What a rack that one’s got,’ was the first thing I thought.”

What a rack, indeed.

At 355-2/8, the final score replaced the former World’s Record by over half as many points, but it was not officially scored until 1960. However, the rack was impressive enough that a drawing of it appeared in the 1939 edition of North American Big Game. Broder acknowledged his record with the determined words of a true sportsman.

“I started hunting in the year 1909 and have never missed a season since; I am now 72 and in fair health. Who can tell, I may yet beat my old 1926 record.”

Editor’s Note: The Boone & Crockett Club has long been a conservation organization that stands and strives for the preservation and well-being of all big game animals, but especially the mule deer. As one of America's most popular game species, it carries a storied history and a promising future.

Don’t Miss: Rack Report: Devin Moore's Alberta Monster

Are you a deer hunter thirsty for knowledge? Check out our stories, videos and hard-hitting how-to's on deer hunting.

Follow us on Facebook.

More Booners

  • A Near-200 Inch Typical from the North
  • The Ross Buck: A Giant Public Land Mule Deer
  • The Simmons Buck: A 275-Inch First Deer
  • A Century-Long Story of a Lost Buck